In August 2021, Fatone got together with a few other 90s heartthrobs including Backstreet Boys members Nick Carter and AJ McLean, along with Wanya Morris from Boyz II Men. The event, known as The After Party, was multiple nights of performances, bringing back timeless hits. "We always try to have combinations of different people and that's what the After Parties were, because I love performing," said Fatone. "It's almost like a Rat Pack idea."

While Fatone is still out performing as much as he can, getting other stars out with him along the way, it's not likely a full NSYNC reunion is coming up any time soon. "As far as NSYNC is concerned, never say never, but I know right now that nothing's happening," he said. "[There's] no talks about it, because everybody's been doing their own thing."

NSYNC's Chris Kirkpatrick is currently keeping busy on "Celebrity Big Brother." Meanwhile, Lance Bass has his hands full after welcoming twins in October. "It's a little bit crazy as far as getting us together to sit down and say, 'Hey, what do we want to do?' or when are we going to do it, or if we're going to do it," said Fatone.

Joey Fatone's new Schlotzsky's line of freshly baked calzones is available now. The Fatone Calzone is available for a limited time. You can follow the newly-christened Joey Calzone on Instagram.