In 2019, on an episode of "RHOBH," Rinna claimed Sheridan became acquainted with Bolton at his concert, and subsequently left Hamlin, a charge the actress soon denied via Twitter.

"FAKE NEWS! Harry and I ended our marriage nose to nose in Canada...Michael was a long time friend that was invited to our wedding...Happy Harry found happiness with housewife @lisarinna @slice_tv," she tweeted upon the allegations she was unfaithful making headlines.

The plot thickened when Hamlin doubled down on Rinna's version of events about how he and Sheridan split up (via People).

Taking to Twitter, the actor commented, "Re Fake News! What's it called when your wife of one year suddenly goes to bed with a pop singer? ...two weeks after your mother dies?? I did a lotta stuff with my wife 'nose to nose' but ending our marriage was not one of them!"

We may never know the truth — or exactly how Sheridan and Bolton met in the '90s. It's also unclear why they ended their relationship the first time.